304 or 201? Checking stainless steel grades in cookware and kitchenware
Why 201 is sometimes sold as 304, why the magnet test doesn’t settle it, and how to check stainless steel grade at the factory with an XRF analyser.
By Packsel Consulting, Purchasing insights
Article date: · 4 min read
Updated:
Products described as 304 or 18/8 stainless steel need a material specification and a method of verification. Alternative grades such as 201 can look similar when new, so appearance alone is an insufficient basis for accepting the material.
The difference matters. Grade 304 contains roughly 18 percent chromium and 8 percent nickel. Grade 201 replaces much of the nickel with manganese. It costs less and corrodes more easily, particularly with salt and acidic foods. A customer finds rust spots on a pan after a few months, and the reviews follow.
Why the magnet test doesn’t settle it
The usual advice is “304 isn’t magnetic, so use a magnet.” That is only partly true. Annealed 304 is close to non-magnetic, but cold working (deep drawing a pot, rolling a rim) can make it noticeably magnetic. Grade 201 behaves in a similar way. Grade 430, a ferritic stainless, is strongly magnetic and is often used deliberately in induction bases.
So a magnet can tell you a part is probably a ferritic grade like 430. It can’t tell 304 from 201.
Use an XRF analyser
A handheld X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyser reads the alloy composition from the surface in a few seconds. It will show the nickel and manganese content, which separates 304 from 201 clearly. Many inspection teams and some factories own one.
To use it well during an inspection:
- test parts from several cartons, not just the top layer
- test each stainless component separately: body, lid, handle, rivets
- clean any coating or film off the test spot
- record the reading with a photo of the screen next to the part
For high-value or disputed orders, send samples to a lab for a full chemical analysis as well.
Check the material at the source too
Ask the factory for the steel mill certificate for the coil or sheet used for your order. It should state the grade and composition. Mill certificates can be copied from a different batch, so treat them as one piece of evidence and check them against an XRF reading on the finished goods.
Write the grade into the order
The purchase order and specification should state the grade for each component, for example “body and lid: AISI 304; base disc: AISI 430; rivets: 304.” Then the inspection has something definite to check against.
Other checks on stainless cookware
While you’re checking the grade, a pre-shipment inspection on cookware usually also covers:
- wall and base thickness, measured with a gauge
- base flatness, especially for induction use
- handle and rivet strength
- weld and polishing quality on the rim
- any non-stick coating, for adhesion and finish
- markings, such as grade stamps and induction symbols
Other stainless grades you will see
- 316: contains molybdenum for better corrosion resistance. Used for marine and some premium kitchen products.
- 430: ferritic, magnetic and cheaper. Common for induction bases and some cutlery.
- 18/10: a marketing term for an alloy with about 18 percent chromium and 10 percent nickel, usually a version of 304.
- J1, J4 and other 200-series names: low-nickel grades sometimes sold under trade names.
A label that says “stainless steel” without a grade tells you very little.
How we check stainless grades on site
When grade matters, we take an XRF analyser to the inspection. We test parts from several cartons, clean any film off the test spot, and test each stainless component separately: body, lid, handle and rivets. We photograph the analyser screen next to each part. A reading that shows high manganese and low nickel on a product sold as 304 is a finding we report immediately.
Packsel Consulting carries out inspections on kitchenware and housewares, and can check material grades with an XRF analyser where the scope includes it.
About these articles
Packsel Consulting
Purchasing insights · U.S. and Hong Kong
Practical guidance for U.S. businesses buying from Asia.
How we work