Sourcing

Sourcing CNC machined parts in China: drawings, tolerances and quality checks

Prepare comparable machining quotations, define first article inspection requirements and monitor critical dimensions during production.

By Packsel Consulting, Purchasing insights
Article date: · 4 min read
Updated:

When sourcing CNC machined parts in China or elsewhere in Asia, the drawing, supplier quotation and inspection plan need to describe the same requirements. Clear tolerances and first article approval give the production run a defined reference, making deviations easier to identify and discuss.

Provide a controlled drawing

Provide a dimensioned drawing alongside the 3D model. Send a 2D drawing as well, which states:

  • material, including grade and temper, such as 6061-T6 aluminium or 304 stainless
  • general tolerances, and tighter tolerances only on features that need them
  • geometric tolerances for flatness, perpendicularity and position where they matter
  • surface finish (Ra values) and any cosmetic surfaces
  • threads, with standard and class
  • finishing: anodising type and colour, plating, passivation, powder coat
  • the drawing revision

Over-tolerancing is expensive. If every dimension carries ±0.01 mm, the quote will reflect it, and the shop may quietly ignore the ones that don’t seem to matter.

Ask for an itemised quote

A good machining quote separates material, machining time, finishing, inspection and packaging, and states the quantity and lead time. It should also list any exceptions to your drawing, such as a different material grade or a finish they don’t offer. Request written confirmation of those exceptions.

First article inspection

Before a batch is run, ask for a first article inspection (FAI). The shop makes the first part (or first few), measures every dimension on the drawing, and records the results in a report against each dimension.

A useful FAI report includes:

  • a ballooned drawing, with each dimension numbered
  • a table of nominal, tolerance, measured value and result for every balloon
  • the measuring equipment used, such as a CMM, height gauge or thread gauge
  • material certificates and finish certificates
  • photos of the part

The format in AS9102, an aerospace standard, is a well-known template even outside aerospace. You approve the FAI before the batch is made.

Keep it consistent in production

Once the first article is approved, the risk is drift: a worn tool, a new operator, a different material lot. Ask the shop how often it measures parts during the run, which dimensions, and with what. For critical features, ask for in-process measurement records with the shipment.

At pre-shipment inspection, measure a sample of parts on the critical dimensions and check the finish, thread and cosmetic surfaces. A CMM at the shop can be used under observation.

Visit the shop

A visit shows which machines they have (3-axis, 5-axis, lathes, Swiss-type), how they measure, whether the measuring room is controlled for temperature, and whether finishing is done in-house or sent out. Anodising and plating are often subcontracted, which is a common source of colour and thickness variation.

How we review machined parts

On a machining supplier visit, we look at the machines the parts will run on, the measuring room, and how the shop records in-process checks. We review the first article report against the drawing and spot-check critical dimensions ourselves on sample parts. We check where finishing such as anodising or plating is done, because subcontracted finishes are a common source of variation.

Mistakes to avoid when sourcing machined parts

  • Sending a 3D model without a dimensioned 2D drawing.
  • Applying tight tolerances to every dimension.
  • Approving production without a first article report.
  • Forgetting that finishes are often subcontracted.

Packsel Consulting sources machining suppliers, verifies shops before you order and follows first article approval as part of production oversight.

About these articles

Packsel Consulting

Purchasing insights · U.S. and Hong Kong

Practical guidance for U.S. businesses buying from Asia.

How we work
More insights

Get in touch

Tell us what you’re buying.

Send us the product, the supplier if you have one, and your dates. We’ll suggest a scope for one stage or the whole order.