Comparing suppliers in China, Vietnam, Thailand and Malaysia on equal terms
Compare Asian supplier quotations using consistent specifications, delivery terms and landed-cost assumptions before changing your sourcing arrangements.
By Packsel Consulting, Purchasing insights
Article date: · 4 min read
Updated:
Comparing a new supplier in Vietnam, Thailand or Malaysia with an existing Chinese supplier requires more than a review of unit prices. Specifications, delivery terms and import-cost assumptions must align before the quotations provide a meaningful basis for a sourcing decision.
The first step is to confirm that the quotations describe the same requirements and commercial scope.
Send every supplier the identical brief
Start with one written brief: materials, dimensions, finishes, packaging, labelling, quantities by SKU and the testing you need. Send the same document, with the same revision number, to every supplier in every country.
When quotes come back, check what each one assumed. One factory priced a thinner gauge. Another left out the printed inner box. A third quoted a minimum order three times your volume. Identify these differences before comparing prices, and request revised quotations where the scope does not align.
Quote on the same Incoterm
A FOB Ho Chi Minh City price and an EXW Dongguan price can’t be compared directly. EXW leaves you paying for inland trucking and export clearance; FOB includes them. Ask everyone to quote FOB at a named port, or convert each quote yourself and note what you added.
Work out the landed cost, not the factory price
The factory price is one line. To compare countries you need roughly:
| Cost line | What changes between countries |
|---|---|
| Unit price | Labour, material availability, scale |
| Inland freight to port | Distance from factory to port |
| Ocean freight | Lane, port, service frequency |
| Duty | Classification, country of origin, any additional tariffs |
| Brokerage and fees | Usually similar, but check |
| Inventory cost | Longer transit or lead time ties up cash |
Duty is often the reason for the move, so be careful with it. The rate depends on classification and on where the goods are legally made, which isn’t always where they’re assembled. See our note on country of origin before you build a plan on a lower rate.
Ask where the materials come from
Many factories in Southeast Asia import components, fabrics or resin from China. Imported inputs may affect lead times and origin assessments, and can retain dependencies on the original supply market. Ask each supplier which inputs are made locally and which are imported.
Check capability, not just the sample
A good sample proves the factory can make one good unit. It doesn’t show whether it can make 20,000 at the same standard. Ask about the production line that will run your order, the equipment, current workload and whether any process is subcontracted. A visit settles a lot of this quickly.
Plan a pilot order
If the numbers still favour the new country, place a smaller first order with a pre-shipment inspection and compare the result with your current supplier. Maintain communication with the existing supplier while assessing the new supplier’s delivery and performance.
Which products suit which country
Each country has clusters of capability. Broadly:
- Vietnam: furniture, apparel and footwear, and a growing electronics assembly base.
- Thailand: automotive parts, rubber products, electronics and food processing.
- Malaysia: electronics and semiconductors, rubber gloves and medical devices.
- China: the widest range, from components to complete machinery, with the deepest supply chains for materials and parts.
These are generalisations. Individual factories vary, and many products still depend on components from China wherever final assembly happens.
How we run a cross-country comparison
When a client wants to compare China with Vietnam or Thailand, we send one brief to suppliers in each country and ask for quotes on the same Incoterm. We then put the quotes in one table with landed cost, lead time, minimum order and the open questions for each supplier. Where the decision is close, we visit the shortlisted factories in each country, because a capability that exists on paper doesn’t always exist on the floor.
Packsel Consulting runs supplier searches across Asia, verifies new suppliers and provides tariff consulting so the comparison holds up.
About these articles
Packsel Consulting
Purchasing insights · U.S. and Hong Kong
Practical guidance for U.S. businesses buying from Asia.
How we work